Navigating the College Sports Application Process
From Recruiting Calls to Reality – A Guide for Student-Athletes Facing the Challenges of College Applications
Hey everyone,
With college applications in full swing, many student-athletes are feeling the pressure—not just to get into the best academic programs but also to find the right fit for their sport. It’s a daunting process, no doubt—one that I remember all too well from my days as a high school fencer looking to continue my journey into college.
In this edition of The Next Arena, I’m diving into my own experiences navigating the college sports world and offering some advice for athletes starting their own journeys. From finding the right program to managing expectations, here are some tips to help you out.
The Decision Process: Finding the Right Program
When I was applying to colleges for fencing, my biggest challenge was finding the best program that aligned with what I wanted to achieve. I knew I wanted to attend a school with a strong fencing program, but I also wanted to dive into academics and think about what I’d pursue after my time in sports. It wasn’t just about athletics; it was about finding a balance that made sense for my future.
You’re going to feel a lot of pressure to pick the right program. Coaches will try to sell you on their school, their team, and their facilities, but remember—you’re the one making the decision. I kept asking myself: what would make me happy as both a student and an athlete?
Tip: Be clear about what you want from a program. Prioritize both athletic and academic goals. You won't get what you don't ask for, so make sure you're transparent with coaches and recruiters about your needs.
Balancing Academics and Sports
When I started applying, balancing academics with my fencing training was already a challenge. So, when I had to factor in college visits, conversations with recruiters, and writing essays, it became even more intense. I had to stay really intentional with my schedule—making notes, blocking out time, and focusing on what mattered.
Being intentional is key. It’s not just about how much you can fit into your day, but how much you can give to each activity. Quality over quantity is something that applies just as much in training as it does in schoolwork.
Tip: Time management is your best friend. Block out specific time slots for academics, sports, and downtime to avoid burnout. Keep your schedule structured but flexible.
Pressure from Coaches and Recruiters
Let’s be real: college coaches and recruiters can be intense. They want you to commit, and sometimes they want it done quickly. I definitely felt that pressure when schools were telling me why I should join their program and were eager to hear my decision.
What I learned was that I didn’t owe them anything. You don’t owe any of these programs a decision before you’re ready. You want to make the best choice for yourself. One tactic I used was to flip the script: I’d ask them, “Why do you think I’m a good fit for your program?” It was important to hear why they wanted me, not just why their school was good. This gave me more clarity about where I could truly thrive.
Tip: Don’t let pressure from coaches rush your decision. Ask questions and find out why they want you. This will help you make a more informed choice.
Expectations vs. Reality: After Joining Penn State
Once I joined Penn State, I quickly realized that I had to step up my game. I was no longer just representing myself—I was part of a highly competitive team. The transition from club fencing to a university program was a big shift. I was used to competing for my club, but now it was all about the team, and we had a common goal to achieve together.
Balancing academics and athletics was tough, but I thrived under the pressure. I won NCAA championships individually back-to-back my freshman and sophomore years, made the Dean’s List every semester, and, on top of that, I was also traveling for international competitions with the USA Team. The expectations were high, but the experience pushed me to grow both as a fencer and a student.
Tip: When you join a college sports team, understand that you’re now competing as part of a unit. Be prepared to step up both in academics and in your sport.
The Importance of Asking for What You Want
Here’s one major tip: you won’t get what you don’t ask for. Be transparent about what you’re looking for in a program, both athletically and academically. If something’s important to you, make sure to ask for it. Don’t be afraid to gather as much information as possible, and don’t hesitate to request the answers you need. This is your future.
Also, make sure you’re actively making connections. Reach out to recruiters, coaches, and staff. With so many athletes applying, you want to ensure you stand out. Don’t be discouraged by rejection either—it’s all part of the process. I had programs choose other athletes over me, and while it was disappointing at the time, I’m thankful now because it helped me land in the right spot. You want to be at a school that wants you just as much as you want to be there.
Tip: Always ask for what you want and stay persistent in making connections. Rejection isn’t failure—it’s a step toward finding the right fit for you.
Coping with Unexpected Challenges
I remember being in Luxembourg for an Olympic qualifier in early 2020, and the athletes were chatting about a virus spreading through Europe—COVID-19. At first, we didn’t think much of it. People were saying it would blow over in a couple of weeks. But two weeks after we returned, the U.S. border closed.
Three months later, I was living in Cambridge with a close friend and training partner. What we once thought was a two-week break turned into months of uncertainty. The Olympics were postponed, and gyms, fencing halls—everything—was closed. The only thing not canceled? My job. At first, it was fun to have a break from everything, but reality hit soon after. Will the Olympics happen? Do I need a backup plan?
Tip: Sometimes life throws you curveballs. Stay adaptable, continue training (even when it’s hard), and always have a backup plan in mind.
Final Thoughts
The college sports application process can be daunting, but the more prepared and intentional you are, the better. Surround yourself with the right people, ask the right questions, and make decisions that benefit you in the long run. And most importantly, stay focused on what matters to you.
Good luck to all the athletes out there navigating this process—you’ve got this!
Best,
Andrew
Have Questions? Let’s Chat!
I hope this insight into my journey and the college sports application process has been helpful for you. If you have any questions or thoughts, feel free to drop a comment or reach out. I’m happy to answer and provide more guidance on anything you might be curious about. Good luck with your own path, and remember to stay focused and keep pushing forward!
Great article! Thoughtful, helpful advice!